AFRICANGLOBE – According to a new report, the recent recession, with its string of foreclosures that are disproportionately affecting Black people, demonstrates that policies encouraging homeownership as a path to building wealth in Black communities are flawed.
The average White family holds significantly greater wealth than the average Black family, and housing wealth comprises a far greater share of total assets for Black families than for White families. Being too strongly tied together, housing and wealth-building policies place communities of color at greater risk of downturns in the housing market as happened in the Great Recession.
“State of the Dream 2013: A Long Way From Home,” the 10th annual Martin Luther King Jr. Day report by United for a Fair Economy (UFE), explains that the Great Recession took a greater portion of wealth from Black families than it did from White families. Today, the average net worth of White families is, respectively, more than six times higher and 5.7 times higher than the average Black families. Median wealth disparities are even greater.
“We focus on wealth disparities because it is linked to a host of other socioeconomic inequities – health, education, income, opportunities and economic security among them. If we seriously reduce wealth inequity, it would go a long way toward resolving many of the other inequities,” says Brian Miller, executive director of UFE and co-author of the report.
The overall economic well-being of Black families is more heavily affected by housing value than it is for White families. On average, home value accounts for roughly half of the total assets held by Black families, but only 28 percent of the total assets held by White families.
“The hemorrhaging of wealth in Black communities stems largely from treating housing policy as an asset-building policy, rather than as two distinct strategies,” says co-author Tim Sullivan. “By trying to do housing and asset-building with the same policy, we’re actually doing neither of them well.”
Today, the average net worth of White families is, respectively, more than six times higher times higher than the average Black families. Median wealth disparities are even greater.
UFE explores how federal housing policy impacts wealth disparities among White, Black and other minority families, noting that there are benefits to homeownership for families and communities, but that there are also drawbacks to tying wealth to housing to too great a degree.
The report argues that federal investments in housing policy should be directed more toward treating housing as a human right and less toward encouraging homeownership as a wealth-building strategy.
“What’s the point of a policy without a goal?” asks co-author Maz Ali. “We can’t have effective housing or asset-building policies without first being clear about what we want to achieve with those policies. And we certainly can’t address the economic struggles in Black communities with policies that ignore race as a factor.”
The report’s recommendations include:
- Limiting the benefit of the Home Mortgage Interest Deduction going to the richest taxpayers;
- Investing in proactive asset-building policies that do not link wealth creation to housing;
- Investing in affordable housing and policies that reach people for whom homeownership is not the best or most viable option; and
- Encouraging alternative models that build community wealth, such as cooperative ownership structures.
United for a Fair Economy is a national, independent, nonpartisan, 501(c)(3) non-profit organization working to raise public awareness of the destructive effects of concentrated wealth and power and supporting the movement for greater economic equality.